Site Overlay

When Is a Civil War Image a Trading Card?

My story as an image collector has its roots in baseball cards. During my early teens, I glimpsed an ad in Baseball Digest to purchase the entire set of 660 Topps baseball cards. I leapt at the chance, persuaded my mom to send a check, and received a long white box filled with pristine cards. The gratification of having scored the complete set at one time triggered a waning interest in baseball cards that effectively ended my interest in collecting them.

The next year, at a flea market, I discovered cartes de visite. An impression formed in the recesses of my brain: This was an infinite series of cards. I could never collect them all.

I found a new collectible.

Holabird Americana Auctions.
Holabird Americana Auctions.

Flash forward to a few months ago. I was contacted by Patric M. Verrone, who watched a YouTube video I created about Cardomania. In it, I mused about the relationship between cartes de visite and baseball cards. Patric asked if I had explored the subject further (I hadn’t) and pointed me to a February 2026 video, General Sherman and the Origins of Baseball, from the YouTube channel Dan’s Vintage Baseball PC. Dan acquired a portrait of Maj. Gen. William T. Sherman published in the carte de visite format by lithographer and printer Louis Prang. A section of Dan’s video discusses how two players in the authentication business, Sportscard Guaranty Corporation (SGC) and Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA), had graded the Prang cartes.

Dan’s findings helped me to appreciate that within the infinite realm of cartes were finite series that could be graded.

Patric also shared a 2017 story providing additional perspective, “Are CDVs and Cabinet Cards Baseball Cards? Yes, No and Maybe” by David Cycleback, an art and artifacts scholar. The post appears on the Society for American Baseball Research’s blog.

Cycleback explains that cartes de visite and cabinet cards of baseball players qualify as trading cards only when commercially issued for public collecting.

I appreciate Cycleback’s reasoning and conclusions. Viewed in this light, the Prang lithographs qualify as gradable cards. So would the carte de visite portraits of military and political leaders photographed by Brady and mass-produced by the Anthony brothers.

On the flip side, a carte de visite of a fresh-faced citizen volunteer in the ranks of a regiment does not qualify. Though you might argue the pack of a dozen cartes he purchased from a photographer is technically a set, they were not created for collecting by the public at large.

I welcome your views.

Ronald S. Coddington
Editor & Publisher


SPREAD THE WORD: We encourage you to share this story on social media and elsewhere to educate and raise awareness. If you wish to use any image on this page for another purpose, please request permission.

Scroll Up