By Paul Russinoff
Those who have studied President Abraham Lincoln and his administration will immediately recognize the face of the man seated on the left in this portrait. He is John Milton Hay, Lincoln’s witty, confident and undeniably brilliant personal secretary.
Though the face may be familiar, the attire is not. In the handful of wartime photographs of Hay, he is nattily dressed in civilian clothes. But here, in this small, trimmed albumen print, he sports a bandbox fresh officer’s uniform complete with the shoulder straps of a major.

Paul Russinoff Collection.
The print is the only known photograph of Hay in Union blue. In it, he sits with Lt. Col. Edward W. Smith. The portrait is a memento of a friendship. It is also a unique visual artifact connected to a highly sensitive diplomatic effort.
Hay was, in fact, an officer. His commission was rushed through Congress in early 1864. On January 11, Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton nominated him as major and assistant adjutant general. The Senate approved the request the next day, and 25-year-old Hay accepted the commission on January 13.
Stanton arranged for the commission at the request of Lincoln, who had tapped Hay for a high stakes mission. About a month earlier, on Dec. 8, 1863, the president issued an executive order with far-reaching potential. The Proclamation of Amnesty and Reconstruction allowed a seceded state to reenter the Union if 10 percent of its voters, as calculated in the 1860 election, signed a loyalty oath to the federal government. The state’s citizens would receive a full restoration of rights and property, with the notable exception of slaves.
Lincoln’s “Ten-Percent Plan” was also a compromise to opposing policy agendas by the Radical Republicans and Peace Democrats.

Florida was targeted as the ideal place to begin. Only 1,435 signatures, 10 percent of its voters, would be necessary to fulfill the basic requirements for readmission. Lincoln tasked Hay with a trip to the state to put the plan in effect. The president also deemed it necessary that Hay should be commissioned an officer to give him authority as he navigated Union military bureaucracy along the way. To further bolster his commission, Hay was appointed as an aide-de-camp on the staff of Maj. Gen. Quincy A. Gilmore, who commanded the Army of the South and was in charge of operations in Florida.
On January 15, barely 48 hours after Hay signed his commission paper, he departed by sea for Hilton Head, S.C. Hay arrived four days later and immediately met Lt. Col. Smith. The two men had encountered one another the year before. In mid-1863, Lincoln had dispatched Hay to Florida—his first trip to the state. Here, he became acquainted with Smith, who at the time served as assistant adjutant general to Maj. Gen. David Hunter. Smith became something of a professional and social companion to Hay during the two-month tour. Hay mentioned Smith several times in his diary, including a reference to being entertained by his rendition of a number of Hymns one evening.
