By Dan Clendaniel
When he enlisted into the Union army, Lt. John E. Michener could not have imagined that his first armed encounter would occur in his Pennsylvania hometown.
Shortly after joining the 85th Pennsylvania Infantry in the late summer of 1861, the 24-year-old Michener was sent on a recruiting trip by his colonel, Joshua B. Howell. The destination was Michener’s home in Fredericktown, Washington County, located in the southwestern part of the state

The timing of the visit was critical. The Union had just been handily defeated at Bull Run in Virginia, and Howell, like many prominent northerners, was anxious to organize a new three-year regiment to help defeat the rebellion of southern states and restore the Union.
Michener’s trip, on Sept. 26, 1861, initially succeeded. Local pro-war speakers helped the young lieutenant gather up eight volunteers to join the regiment. The group planned to travel by steamboat up the Monongahela River to Brownsville, and then overland to Uniontown, Howell’s hometown and the site of Camp Lafayette, where the 85th trained and drilled.
As Michener prepared to board the steamboat near Brownsville at Fredericktown, a small but aggressive group of anti-war citizens voiced their opinions of Michener’s efforts.
Southwestern Pennsylvania was a stronghold of the Democratic Party, but, as in other regions of the country, secession had divided the area into pro- and anti-war factions.
Michener, ardently pro-war, encountered anti-war Dr. Alexander Patton, who soon became a Copperhead in the state legislature. Patton launched a loud diatribe against the war and the administration of President Abraham Lincoln. An argument ensued as citizens on both sides confronted each other. Offended by what he considered as unpatriotic remarks, Michener’s older brother, Ezra, jumped into the fray.
As Ezra launched into a pro-war statement, another anti-war advocate, burly James C. Burson, 35, grabbed him by the throat and knocked him to the ground. Burson’s father, 66-year-old Abraham Burson, who was also Dr. Patton’s father-in-law, lunged at Ezra with a knife and barely missed him.
Michener came to his brother’s defense, aimed a pistol in the direction of the elder Burson and pulled the trigger. But the weapon did not fire. In the heat of the moment, Michener forgot that he had emptied the weapon prior to the recruiting mission.
No one was seriously hurt in the melee.
Michener collected his wits and wisely hustled his recruits to the river, and steamed away before the fight escalated. Michener’s father, Milton, who witnessed the event, noted, “It was well the boat came when it did for I never saw such excitement.”
For Michener, the Battle of Fredericktown, as Milton named it, marked and unusual beginning to an eventful military career. A peacetime clerk, he and his wife, Priscilla, or “Cillie,” had lived in the Washington County town of East Bethlehem. Their first child, Maude, was in August 1861—about the time Michener joined the army.
After Michener disembarked his recruits from the boat in Brownsville, he took a moment to write his siblings. “I leave Brownsville on Friday morning with my recruits … If you can find any men no matter about their character (for that is all righted in camp) bring them or send them up.” He continued on with the recruits to Uniontown and Camp Lafayette, where he reunited with his comrades in Company D and the rest of the 85th. Despite Michener’s efforts, the ranks of his company and others were not completely filled. Men from nearby counties, namely Greene, Fayette and Somerset, were brought in to complete the regiment’s enlistment.
Six weeks later, in late November, the men boarded trains at Uniontown for Washington, D.C., amid a cheering throng of family members and local citizens. They soon arrived in the nation’s capital and joined other troops in Washington’s defenses.
In the spring of 1862, the 85th embarked on Maj. Gen. George B. McClellan’s Peninsula Campaign in Virginia, designed to capture Richmond and end the war. After a few weeks of marching on muddy, rain-swollen roads in cold weather, and without adequate clothing, sickness had reduced the ranks of the regiment by nearly 50 percent. By the end of May, the 85th, part of the division of Brig. Gen. Silas Casey in the Fourth Corps commanded by Maj. Gen. Erasmus D. Keyes, had established a base at Seven Pines, six miles from Richmond and far in advance of the rest of McClellan’s army.
In this area, Michener would experience his first taste of battle.
On the night of May 30, Michener and his captain, John Horn, led their Company D to the picket line during a driving thunderstorm.
“Our little division was attacked by an overwhelming force of the enemy’s best men, and after suffering a heavy loss, was repulsed, but not until we had caused hundreds of rebels to bite the dust!”
Early the next afternoon, Confederates swept down upon Casey’s exposed division, temporarily separated from McClellan’s other three corps by the swollen waters of the Chickahominy River. The Battle of Seven Pines, or Fair Oaks, had begun.
